MANAGING INSECT RESISTANCE IN SEED TRAITS
Bt crops have helped Canadian growers manage insect pests for more than two decades. Unfortunately, the development of resistance to these Bt corn hybrids is inevitable. However, growers can employ strategies to delay this and prolong the life of these important tools.
Growers can slow down the development of insect resistance to Bt crops by practicing Integrated Pest Management (IPM). This approach uses multiple tools, such as cultural, biological and mechanical controls, to manage key pests within a long-term strategy. Start today and take it one field at a time.
- Scout your fields to know what pests are present and how much damage they have caused.
- Correct identification and monitoring of corn pests are critical to making effective pest management decisions.
- Know what pests should be controlled by the Bt corn being grown – not all corn pests are controlled by Bt traits.
Scouting fields for insect damage is unnecessary as long as all other Integrated Pest Management practices are followed:
- Best option: do not plant corn in the same field in consecutive years, grow a different crop entirely in alternating years.
- Alternative option: if planting corn consecutively, avoid planting Bt crops in the same field two years in a row. Use non-Bt varieties. This gives insects less exposure to Bt proteins, thereby slowing resistance developing.
Rotate traits for the target pest
- Best option: plant Bt hybrids with multiple modes of action (MOAs) for the target pest whenever possible.
- Alternative option: if a multiple-MOA product is not an option, rotate to a different Bt trait hybrid or use a non-Bt hybrid with insecticide.
- Consult this Bt traits table for a complete list of traits available in Canada.
1. Insect seed trait resistance best practices include: (select all that apply)
2. It is good practice to avoid planting Bt crops in the same field two years in a row.
- Refuge planting is mandatory and involves planting part of each field (or adjacent field) with a non-Bt hybrid of the same crop. This allows some non-resistant insects to survive and mate with resistant insects, producing non-resistant offspring.
There are two types of refuge:
- Integrated refuge: bag containing Bt seed mixed with non-Bt seed
- Structured refuge: a specific area that you plant with a refuge hybrid alongside your Bt hybrid
A structured refuge is a specific area in a field planted with a refuge hybrid alongside a Bt hybrid.
- Insecticides can be used in place of Bt crops to manage many pests. Before considering this, refer to Evaluating the Need for Insecticide Application.
- Insects can also develop resistance to insecticides. For this reason, rotation of insecticide groups/MOAs is also critical. Refer to Insecticide Best Practices for more information about MOAs and application BMPs. Consider rotation of traited corn and conventional corn with use of insecticides.
When insecticides are used in place of Bt crops to manage pests, there is less concern about resistance.
- Keep accurate records of where traited and conventional corn has been planted and which hybrids were planted. This helps both you and your crop advisors compare the performance of your transgenic and refuge hybrids. It also helps to recognize a problem of suspicious feeding activity in the transgenic corn.
It’s important to keep accurate records of where Bt hybrids are planted because… (Select all that apply)
You can do these steps with the help of your seed company representative, provincial extension specialist, crop advisor, and/or agronomist.
FOLLOW THESE STEPS FOR INVESTIGATING INSECT DAMAGE IN YOUR BT CORN
- SCOUT – Scout both Bt and non-Bt corn for insect damage to crop.
- FIELD INVESTIGATION – Rule out other causes for damage, evaluate pest presence/pressure, verify correct planting and confirm trait presence.
- CONTACT SEED COMPANY – If damage exceeds expected thresholds (“unexpected damage”) and other causes are ruled out, your seed company representative must be among the people informed.
- BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES – Based on the outcome of the evaluation, your seed company will advise on IPM practices to mitigate or reduce pest pressure.
- COLLECT INSECTS – Based on the outcome of the evaluation, the seed company may arrange for samples of the insects in the impacted field to be collected for further lab evaluation. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) will also be notified at this time by the original trait developer.
- RESISTANCE MITIGATION – If resistance is confirmed, you will be informed of any further mitigation actions that may be needed (see below).
The mitigation strategy is developed by a team of experts and will not be one size-fits-all. Measures will be dependent on which hybrids are impacted, what tools are available to the grower, and the extent of the issue. The trait provider will communicate any needed mitigation measure with growers and all relevant stakeholders. Some common mitigation practices could include:
- Rotate to a non-host crop.
- Scout your fields to know what is there.
- Use a pyramid MOA (i.e., multiple MOAs against the same pest). For more information please see the factsheet: Bt Corn 101
- If using a single MOA, be sure to plant the appropriate refuge area and rotate the Bt trait.
- Consider use of a foliar insecticide.
EUROPEAN CORN BORER
- Rotate crop or trait.
- Scout your fields to know what is there.
- Use a pyramid MOA.
- Consider an insecticide to reduce population density.
- Destroy corn stalks in the field at the end of the season.
Watch this video to learn more about managing insect resistance in Bt corn:
Watch the Resistance Management School videos to learn more!
Kelly Turkington discusses: How do diseases become resistant to fungicides and what can we do about it?
Scouting and rotation key to maintaining effective pulse fungicides.
Albert Tenuta talks about the state of fungicide resistance in eastern Canada and recommends best management practices
In this episode we’re talking about how herbicide resistant weeds spread across Ontario and the continent.
How do you assess your risk of developing resistant weeds on your farm?
Manitoba farmer Gunther Jochum talks about their wild oat issues in this episode of the Resistance Management School.
Dr. Linda Hall discusses the state of herbicide resistance in Western Canada, and what growers can do about it.
Mike Cowbrough of OMAFRA joins us to discuss testing for herbicide resistance.
Lauren Benoit from the University of Guelph talks about how to manage multiple resistance in water hemp, discovered earlier this year in Ontario.
Kelvin Heppner talks to Rob Gulden about seeding rates in this episode of the Resistance Management School.
Dr. Peter Sikkema discusses the status of herbicide-resistant weeds in Ontario and provides growers with some best management practices.
More resistance management videos
Fungicide Resistance Management
Insecticide Resistance Management
CropLife International and IRAC explains the importance of mode of action in insect resistance management.